Assignment Task
Public health versus private freedom?
Singer SCAP example • In his brief commentary, Public health versus private freedom?, Singer (2015) asks about whether limits on freedom are justifiable in order to prevent harm, to the person and to others • They focus on the example of plain packaging and graphic images on cigarette packs; Singer thinks that the deadliness and addictiveness malces cigarettes worse than other things already (justifiably) banned by the state • Significant tax-payer/social costs. Smoking will kill a billion people in 21st century • Mill’s harm principle would reject a ban, but allow for plain packaging 1. According to Singer, Mill is outdated: We are susceptible to unconscious biases and influences (e.g. targeted advertising). And, once we start smoking, become addicted 2. As such, we may not actually be the best guardians of our own interestel.’
(b) 1 potential objection • Potential Objection to Singer, view? • While I am sympathetic to the general orientation of the conclusion, Singer is not convincing in their claim that Mill is outdated, or that Mill’s view on respect for individual liberty “verges on naivety” (120); Indeed, Singer uses the same reasoning to support their own conclusion: `plain packaging laws should be embraced as methods for promoting autonomous decision making, in a context rigged already by private corporations that do not have our best interests at heart’ (120-21). Thus, it is misleading (confusing) to suggest that a different argument is needed in favour of plain packaging, beyond inferences drawn directly from Mill, view.
Welcome to our Online Essay Writing Agency. Securing higher grades costing your pocket? Order your assignment online at the lowest price now! Our online essay writers are able to provide high-quality assignment help within your deadline. With our homework writing company, you can order essays, term papers, research papers, capstone projects, movie review, presentation, annotated bibliography, reaction paper, research proposal, discussion, or another assignment without having to worry about its originality – we offer 100% original content written completely from scratch
A-Plus Writing Help For University Students
Get expert assistance in any academic field. All courses and programs covered.
Get Help Now!We write papers within your selected deadline. Just share the instructions
